Sometimes, I think the random number generator is just being mean. Look at this, my reward from this morning's Headless Horseman kill:
Pretty cool, huh? Except - I had every single item in the bag already. Except for the sword. Which I can't use.
Grrr.
(I also don't want to think about how many people who've been waiting years for one of the items in there are now going "nooooooooooo…")
