BRK challenged people to post screenshots from 2006 or earlier. Easy.
As Psia pointed out, there's a shot of the pair of us from May 2005 on our guild blog. And here's one of Leafy from February 2005, the month the game launched in Europe:
(You can see the full original screenshot by clicking on the icon to the right)
I believe Shaleigh is long deleted, but Buliwyf is still very much active as Andro's alt.
2006 indeed. n00bs.
